Post
by Сергей Владимирович. » Thu Jul 22, 2010 15:21
Another proof that you are famously bred.
Mr. ASD apparently had read somewhere different theories, not really understanding their essence, and on the basis of their allegedly created their pseudo-scientific developments. I thought perhaps that here all FUCKERS! I was interested in the theory of space-time, and SRT and GRT, and even deduced the Lorentz transformation, on the basis of Maxwell's equations, and on the basis of group theory. So I know about substantial, and about the relational theory of space-time. It's just the most convenient theoretical model to describe the properties of the world, requires thorough scientific and experimental study. So what technologies are you going to reduce the degeneracy is removed by the spatial – temporal structures and change the human genome? Bullshit! Only one development of this scientific concept, unless it would be recognized as valid in the scientific community (which I strongly doubt), you and your team were to receive the Nobel prize! But it is clear you are a modest man, and thank you don't need. You are trying for the people and for the people are GOOD! So ashamed, Mr. ASD hammer head people any pseudo-scientific nonsense, in which they a little that understand!
The concept of substance
The concept of substance is extremely clearly as in the natural Sciences and the methodology of science. Often under the substance understand the essence, the existential status which is different from the status of material particles-fermions, for example the space field, physical vacuum, or in historical terms — the phlogiston, the luminiferous elastic ether, entelechy...
In the context of problematic work about the time I propose to understand the substance a kind of matter different from the one presented particles-fermions, atoms and molecules of substrates belonging to the deep levels of the structure of matter and may not be directly identifiable in existing experimental technologies.
Before to make a choice between the relational and substantial conceptions of time, consider the examples of implementation of each of them.
Examples of structures of time
In modern natural Sciences the time is initial and undefined notion. A meaningful discussion of the properties of time becomes possible only after the restructuring of the conceptual framework of individual disciplines (Levich, 1993) . Namely, after replacing the time in the source terms of other basic postulates. Based on new postulates, it becomes possible to build models (designs) of time, where its properties are not axioms, implicitly posed by the intuition of the researcher, and “theorems” (literally or figuratively) . Note that the notions of time are (Levich, 1996а) split on the structure of variability of interest (“time-effect” , by L. S. Shikhobalov (1997a) , “the nature of time” , “redrama” ) and design of measurement variability using a reference of variability — hours (“parametric time” ) . Among the many motives for the study of time (Levich, 1993) note the need for explicit design of time when the search for the fundamental equations of the generalized motion of objects of natural history. In fact, the equations of motion describe the variation the researcher is interested in objects with variability of some reference objects — hours. So, from a professed Explorer of nature and a particular implementation of measurement standards variability is highly dependent on the ability of the researcher to withdraw or to “see” , guess we need a law of variability.
Relational approaches. V. V. Aristov (1996) introduces a statistical relational model. Are postulated: a three-dimensional space, the existence of a large number of material particles, the mechanical motion of these particles in space and a sequence of “experiments” on the measurement of the position of the particles. Enter the time interval between “experiments” as an average of the squares of the increments of the radii-vectors of the particles. The model allows to deduce the Galilean transformation, the analogues of the equations of motion of mechanics, to discuss properties the uniformity of the progress and irreversibility of time. The model allows for relativistic generalization.
Yu. s. Vladimirov (1996а, b) offers a relational interpretation of physical space-time in the framework of the innovative machine binary geometrophysics, which generalizes to complex-valued relations the theory of physical structures Yu. I. Kulakov (1968) . This theory postulated two basic sets of elements (particles) for each pair are given by a complex number (the ratio) . Postulated rank of the considered structure, the number of arbitrary elements to their original sets for which written fundamental law in the theory of physical structures. This law is postulated in the form: for a complete set of relations for the selected arbitrary elements of the determinant of Cayley-Menger equal to zero. Such a law grade 3 generates a prototype of the 4-dimensional classical space-time of special relativity with its dimension, metric, topology.
In the case of rank 4 it's a geometry of curved space-time of Riemann type. In the theories of rank 5 and 6 there are means for describing physical interactions in the spirit of multidimensional theories of Kaluza-Klein. Binary geometrophysics naturally appear spinor, massive particles — leptons and hadrons, the gauge group, supersymmetry and quasiconformal transformations, displayed a prototype of the Dirac equation. Two of the initial set theory are interpreted as initial and final States of the system under study that can be considered as a basis for constructing the flow and focus of the model time.
Another example implementation of the relational approach gives a typological concept of time by S. V. Meyen (Sharov, 1996) . In this biological concept postulated: combination of individual organisms or taxa (classes) of similar organisms, the space of possible States or characteristics of these objects, and trajectories in such spaces. Time in the typological concept acts as the variability of individuals or taxa, checked on the status of the objects in the spaces of their States or characteristics. Time of the observed objects are projected on to the own variability of the observer, perceive them as something a priori. “With the expansion of Tucson reduced the extent of the generality of its individuals... and depleted the signs of the corresponding class time. Extremely broad Tucson are material objects at all... Then the place of archetypes is a material point, the variability of which is degenerated to the variability in absolute time...” (Meyen, 1982, SS. 365-366) . Typological concept removes the contradiction between the representations of universal and specific time: the degree of universality depends on the volume of the taxon. A practical application of the typological concept of time is the principle of historical reconstructions (Meighan, 1984) . Proposed by A. A. Ball (1996) the development of the typological approach can be a convenient tool for analysis of variability. The approach allows to separate the concepts of time and process, to define the concept of simultaneity, to deduce the law of variation.
A. D. Armand (1996) considers concepts of time in the Earth Sciences an abstraction that generalizes many properties of the real terrestrial and astronomical processes. At the same time they deny the existence of a natural reference process, and his selection is completely related to the reasons of convenience, in a form agreed between the researchers. That is, time is seen not only as a relation but as a Convention.
The substantial approaches. In the middle of this century astrophysicist N. A. Kozyrev introduced in the dynamical description of the World, with “active” properties of the entity do not coincide neither with matter, nor field, nor space in their usual understanding (Kozyrev, 1991) . The author, calling this entity a “flow of time” , never connected it with any of the philosophical concepts. However, his interpreters (Eganova, 1984; Zvirblis, 1994; Arushanov, Korotayev, 1995; Korotaev, 1996; Levich, 1996; Shichobalov, 1996a; Shikhobalov, 1997a) , as a rule, include the views of N. A. Kozyrev to the substantial views. Indeed, N. A. Kozyrev described the new entity is clearly in the “substantial” terms: “time is a huge thread covering all the material processes in the Universe and all the processes occurring in these systems are sources feeding this common stream” (Kozyrev, 1963, p . 96). The author writes about the intensity or density of this flow, its energy, radiation or absorption, the straightness of its distribution, of the reflection from obstructions or absorption of the substance. According To N. A. Kozyrev, time “flows into a system through the cause to the result” (Kozyrev, 1971, p. 118) gives the impression that it “retracts the reason and Vice versa is sealed in that place where there is a consequence” (Kozyrev, 1971, p. 129) shows that “in every process of nature it may take, or be formed” (Kozyrev, 1971, p. 129) . Stream Kozyrev has very exotic properties: it transfers energy, but does not transfer the momentum, “does not apply, and there is a” (i.e., spreading with infinite speed) , “turns causes in the investigation” at a rate proportional to the product of the speed of light constant in atomic fine structure.
In the concept of N. A. Kozyrev is possible to highlight several complementary aspects:
•Claim about the openness of the Universe in relation to energy of “stream of time” , so that this flow is one of the sources of energy of astronomical bodies and the cause of non-compliance with the second law of thermodynamics in the Universe scale.
•The statement about the thread as a “carrier” required for the “transformation of reason in the investigation” , that is, the Kozyrev flow is the source of a new World.
•The statement of the “emission” or “absorption” of the flow of any non-equilibrium process and the impact of flow on many properties of solids — modulus of elasticity, weight, thermal conductivity, density, resistance to electric current, the output of electrons in the photoelectric effect, volume, etc.
•Statement about the power of non-classical influence of the flow on the rotating body.
•Approval of the transfer flow of information about current, past and future (!) the position of stellar objects.
If the first and second approval at the present stage are the non-verified articles of faith developed paradigm, on the experimental verification of other postulates spent decades of labor N. A. Kozyrev and his colleagues, followers, and independent researchers. A number of authors (Kozyrev, 1991; Hayasaka, Takeuchi, 1989; Qwinn, Picard, 1990; Lavrentiev, etc., 1990а, b; 1991; 1992) show the desired effects, other authors (Faller et al., 1990; Nitschke, Wilmarth, 1990; Barashenkov, 1996; Chigarev, 1996; Parchomov, 1996) or do not detect effects at all, or successively eliminating possible causes of error, argue that the available effects can be fully explained by traditional physics of the electrostatic or magnetic weak effect; electromagnetic, in particular heat radiation; mechanical resonance or nonlinear phenomena; convective heat transfer; radiometric effect due to the fact that gas molecules are reflected with greater speed from the warmer parts of measuring instruments. I should add that the perception and meaningful discussion of the results N. A. Kozyrev also hampered by the lack of clear methodological elaboration of the logical framework concept, incoherence of views on the “flow of time” with the conceptual apparatus, methods of theoretical analysis and view of the World of modern science, that is, the failure of the principle of conformity.
Attempting to build a specific physical model of temporal substance makes HP Shikhobalov (Shichobalov, 1996b; Shikhobalov, 1997a, b) . “On the basis of the merger of the substantial conception of time and the fundamental position of modern physics that space and time form a unified four-dimensional manifold, a concept of spatial-time substance. The latter is a four-dimensional manifold, which, first, has the pseudo-Euclidean geometry of Minkowski space... and secondly, endowed with some additional structure that characterizes, in terms of N. A. Kozyrev, physical and active properties of time... it is Assumed that this diversity is the mathematical image of some object actually existing in nature along with matter and physical fields, which justifies the use against him of the term “substance” . In this model, our world is composed of substances and fields, is a three-dimensional hyperplane of simultaneous events, which “moves” through the space-time substance along the time axis... In this model you get a clear sense of the General scientific concepts of time flow and its direction, it is easy to prove the statement about the symmetry of the world, similar to the known CPT-theorem of quantum field theory, it is possible to show that the observed mirror asymmetry of the world and its asymmetry in relation to particles and antiparticles can be a consequence of exposure to the world of spatio-temporal substance.
The model allows for the option in which matter and fields that form our world, are not independent physical realities, but specific structures of spatial-time substance (such as clumps, vortices, etc.) , while overall the world is a single wave similar to a soliton, propagating in the space-time substance in the direction from past to future. This version of the model is diametrically opposed to the relational concept of time, according to which, on the contrary, time is not independent of physical reality, but only a particular manifestation of the properties of matter and fields...
This version of the model is obviously close in some ways to develop a quantum field theory model of physical vacuum, which are born from particles of matter... In our model, even a simple use of the term “substance” as the name of the studied object opens a clear perspective for the development of the theory. It is immediately obvious what to do next: to formulate the defining equation for the substance, to set laws type laws of conservation and motion, to put a boundary value problem, etc. it is also Clear that the development of this model can be used the rich Arsenal of methods of mathematical physics and continuum mechanics. In particular, the description of the substances and fields as structures of spatial-time substance possible use of the ideas and results obtained in the study of dislocations — special structures of the crystal or of continua that are described in theory as an independent physical objects, although in reality are not, and represent only certain States of the crystal or of a continuous medium” (Shikhobalov, 1997a, SS. 374-375) .
The development of the approach allows to build a model of the electron as a structure formed by a four-dimensional substance with the pseudo-Euclidean geometry of Minkowski space (Shikhobalov, 1997б) . Model exactly describes the electromagnetic field of arbitrarily moving charge, without the use of Maxwell's equations.
Model HP Shikhobalov echoes the “new paradigm” M. H. Shulman (1997) . The basis for constructing a cosmological theory based on “objectively existing” 4-dimensional ball. The universe is expanding in 4-dimensional Euclidean space and is a 3-dimensional hypersurface of the ball. The author believes 4-dimensional space identical for all four dimensions, which do not differ among themselves. “Living in a 3-dimensional world, the creatures did not know about the presence of 4-dimensional superspace, if not the process of expansion of the balloon. This process objectively identifies each point of the hypersurface of the ball the direction normal to her not belonging to her. Here is the direction (the 4th dimension) at each point in the 3-dimensional Universe and represents a true time ” (Shulman, 1997, SS. 8-9) . The model requires openness of the Universe-its energy and mass growing proportionally to the radius (i.e. age) of the Universe. Model, not in terms of 3-dimensional images of particles, and “objectively existing” world lines, allows to deduce the law of Hubble, to explain the principle of inertia of Galileo, deduced the Lorentz transformation to explain the phenomenon of the “flow” of time, to construct a cosmological arrow of time, to determine the mass as a kind of quantum number for de Broglie waves, to introduce the concept of particle motion as a purely geometric consequence of the expansion of the balloon, to explain the anisotropy of the CMB.
Note the substantial approach to the “nature” of time Butusov K. P. (1990) , have adopted the idea of mass increase and expansion of elementary particles, and with them the atoms of the bodies due to the “streaming” them from the vacuum of substance with positive energy (or, equivalently, due to the “leakage” of a substance with negative energy) . This hypothesis is an alternative to ideas about the expanding Universe explanation for the red shift in stellar spectra in the derivation of the Hubble law, and also suggests the mechanism of gravity.
In concluding the section on the substantial approach, consider the design of substitutional (i.e. substitutions of elements), natural systems (Levich, 1986; 1989; 1996, of; 1997; Levich, 1993; 1995) . The design of put several principles and definitions. The principle of hierarchy: natural systems include multiple levels of hierarchical structure. The principle of the existence of generating flows: any natural systems are not closed in relation to flows of elements of some levels of their hierarchical structure. The set of elements of each of the generating flows is proposed to call the substance. Design time : one of the levels of the hierarchical structure of a system, there is a generating flow is selected as “frameepisode” and generating the corresponding stream is declared a natural referent of the “current” time (meaning accepted the principle of conventionality : the choice frameepisode level is determined by the goals of the study) . Design substitution hours: interval substitutional time system is replaced in the system number of elements generating a stream of its frameepisode level. The design of the particles of matter: let us call material particle sources or sinks of generating flows in our Universe. Design space : the space is generated by a Union of substances of generating flows of certain levels of the structure of the system, higher than bramairate level. Design substitutional movement: any motion of the system is to replace (i.e. substitution) of the component at the given level of the structure of the elements. Notice that substitution movement in space occurs not by “moving apart” the elements of substance, and through “penetration” of elements in the object and replace the existing object elements (i.e. the “aether wind” , “ether friction” does not exist and the substance of the generating flows in that sense is not “ether” of the nineteenth century) .
Model substitutional time (not always explicitly) provides a number of possibilities for theoretical description of the World:
•The phenomenon of the formation is a reformulation of the hypothesis of the existence of a generating source.
•Naturally occurring “arrow” of time and allowed the “paradox of time” (Prigogine, Stengers, 1994) , which consists in the contradiction between the absolute reversibility in time of the fundamental laws of physics and the apparent distinction between past and future in the world of real processes.
•Finds the resolution of the contradiction between acting in a closed Universe the second law of thermodynamics and the absence of the World traces the degradation and the inevitable movement towards equilibrium (Landau, Lifshitz, 1964, SS. 45-46; Kozyrev, 1963, p . 96).
•Introduced a review of the structure of matter, charges, space, movement, interaction...
•There is the possibility of the conclusion and research of the equations of motion.
•There is a conceptual framework for designing and discussion of such properties substituting the time increment, progress has been uneven, the existence of a timeless event...
•Naturally occurring entropy parameterization of system substitutional time that returns him to a familiar universality.
Notice that the substantial referents of time are implicitly demanded in the solution of natural scientific problems and those authors who do not declare their belonging to any of the methodological concepts. So, the solution of the “paradox of irreversibility” in astrophysics I. Prigogine could not do without a cosmological model with the generation due to the energy of the gravitational field of matter in the form of particles with Planck masses (Prigogine et al., 1989; Prigogine, Stengers, 1994) . In fact, the born flux of matter appears in Prigogine's natural referent of the “flow” of time and sets the arrow of time. However, models with the birth substances parametrized formation and the direction of time, actively discussed in cosmology (Bondi, 1960; Hoyle et al., 1993) .
The substantial aspects of the concept
Time in substantial approaches is a consequence of the openness of the Universe. The variability of the World is generated “flowing” through it, the substance (or substance, or energy) , and the flow is identified with the “flow” of time. In the concept generating streams merge the concept of matter (particles which has a singularity of the flow) , space (the totality of substances of the flow) and time (variability caused by and generic stream) . In fact, substantial beliefs give rise to a new paradigm — an open, nonlinear, self-organizing, increasingly complex generated by the “time” of the World.
It should be emphasized that in most substantial approaches substance is not matter in the form of substrates of complexes of particles possessing charge and interactions. Substance gives rise to these particles, their charges and interactions: “substrate” particle properties are dynamic characteristics of some structures of the substance — concentration (solitary waves, solitons) , vortices, tori, sources, or drains (a good visual image which is the key or the fountain, “beating” in the reservoir) and other types of singularities.
History of science demonstrates the change of the substantial explanations for relational or logical reduction of conceptual entities (note this was brought to Vladimir Aristov) . On changing ideas about phlogiston came from the molecular-kinetic theory of substance, turning the heat from substance to relation. Ideas about elastic svetonosnost the air was replaced by the notion of electromagnetic field. In search of the “essence of life” preferences are not given to the entelechy of Aristotle, and the achievements of molecular biology. But, if the example of the rejection of the phlogiston completely convincing, the rejection of ether has required the introduction of other entities: bosonic form of matter as the carrier of interactions and concept of the physical vacuum as a material referent of physical space. And in regard to the nature of living things, molecular biology has not yet reached sufficient depth of explanation (as, indeed, do not exist and theory, revealing the nature of “vital force” of entelechy) . So, the choice between the relational and substantial approaches, in particular, can be determined by choice of faith in the necessity or the premature introduction into the conceptual apparatus of a new ontological entities.
The development of a substantial approaches in force experimental neidentificate declared in them are substances found in many epistemological difficulties — lack of conventional images and an adequate language of description, empirical benchmarks, the conceptual apparatus. Substantive approaches tend to be rather radical. Reserved configured researcher may be invited to consider substantive hypothesis only as a convenient method of the description of the studied phenomena. That is, if you will, to translate ideas about the substances and flows from the area of ontology in the Arsenal of epistemological approaches.
It is possible to allocate two ways of socialization of substantial ideas. The most direct of them — operational presentation, i.e. reproducible measurement of any features substantial flows outside of their manifestation — the flow of our time. In this way, we are using an analogy from the history of the discovery of electricity, rather in the position of “the frog dancing master” Galvani, than place-holders come down to the present day frame of Faraday. Note also that the adopted here the definition of substance, giving rise to the interaction of the particles, however, does not interact with them. And, apparently, one should not complain about the untested nature of the substantive hypotheses: experimental detection of objects deep levels of matter structure depends not only on the intellectual efforts of theorists, but to a great extent — from the achieved civilization “sum of technologies” (in the words of S. LEM) . Striking examples of this assertion is the distance, in thousands of years between the atomic hypothesis of Democritus and experiments on diffusion of atoms and other experienced evidence of the atomic structure of matter or the distance of a hundred years between proclaimed Mendel's particles of inheritance and carried out by Watson and Crick x-ray structural analysis of the structure of deoxyribonucleic acid. Another way is speculative (speculative) — still “invent hypotheses” : based on the introduced new entities adopt a consistent theoretical construct a consistent picture of the World, to explain known effects, to formulate in experimentally attainable fields, predictions of new effects and, most importantly, to try using substantial approaches to solve the existing problems of natural science. Among such problems (Levich, 1993; 1996а) :
•The nature of the “flow” of time, or formation.
•The nature of the “linearity” of time.
•The paradox of irreversibility — the contradiction between the time reversibility of the fundamental equations of physics, and a clear distinction between past and future in the world of real processes.
•The contradiction between the need for the implementation of the second law of thermodynamics in a closed Universe and the observed absence of visible degradation.
•The lack of generally accepted ways of output, not guess the fundamental equations of a generalized movement in various subject areas of science.
•The need for a unified description of specific times of natural science — physical, biological, psychological, geological, etc., on the one hand, and the need to return time to its universal status on the other.
•The need for adequate measurements of their own age, a very wide spectrum of natural systems of various ranks.
•Difficulties of scientific forecasting.
•Dreams of mankind about the “control” a time of natural systems.
•Difficulties scientific discussion of models of timeless existence.
Notice that the substantial concepts have advantages over relational in solving some of these problems. For example, the decision of problems of formation, irreversibility, lack of “heat death” of the Universe becomes trivial when making hypotheses about openness to the World of generating flows and the identification of some of them with “over” time.
The rejection of opposing concepts
Emphasize that in today's substantiality conceptions of the substance is not time itself. It's only natural referent of the concept of time. The “course” of time is identified with the existing in nature or, in other words, this process is taken to be the standard of variation for the original reference system to commit the changes in the World. The same reference process parameterizes changes in other objects, i.e. used as the main argument for changing all of the functional dependencies of the World, or plays the role of a parametric time. Specified the identification, and allows us to consider the substantial time (to the same extent that its referent) reality and phenomenon. In the relational approaches there is no identification of time with any material essence. Relational time is an ideational construct of the characteristics of material objects, i.e. was the Convention and the noumenon.
However, “there is no relationship without substance” , i.e. any relational approach uses a set of material objects to build relationships between them and on the basis of these relations — design time.
Thus, rising to the height of philosophical generalization, we can conclude that in the substantial and relational approaches time is the motion of matter. In the substantive approach focuses on the media of motion and relational — on the motion or, if desired, upon the particular relationship between the elements of matter, as what can be seen and movement. But as there are no relations without the medium or substance without motion does not give rise to variability. It is important to note that the substantial approach, usually refers to the ordered movement of the — stream (not in the sense of the presence of highlighted areas in a space, but in the sense of increasing the amount of the substance near the source of the substance) . In relational approaches any ordering is not postulated.
The current practice of developing the substantial and relational approaches clearly distinguishes between the status of physical entities, the characteristics of which are identified (substantial approach) or correspond (relational approach) with the properties of time. For substantiality is a “delicate matter” , not identifiable with modern scientific technology. But in relational approaches, for example, nucleons (Aristov, 1996) , “macroscopic objects” (Vladimirov, 1996, p. 16) and molecular constellation.
Thus, the difference between these approaches is in the nuances of the original postulates: in substantiality the approach postulated matter in an unidentifiable modern experimental technologies forms and ordered movement, in the relational approaches postulated matter in the known forms, and the regulation of the movement is not mentioned. It is possible to notice that the substantial and relational approaches, by entering the time using different kinds of different forms of matter, are not the opposition, but complementary to each other.
Their opposition may be more important that the substantial concept of gravitate towards the open-World paradigm, and relational — based on the idea of a closed and isolated systems, but this is not the opposition “communiques or substance” , discussion of which was devoted to this work.<